Let me begin this annual feature with a reset for any new readers out there. I like college football, and I watch a lot of college football on TV. What I have come to do is to keep a notepad next to my seat as I watch games and to make notes about players I see who I believe can be drafted by NFL teams. There is nothing more to it than that:
- I am not a scout; I do not have an extensive network of people like me who are feeding me information on players/games that I do not see myself.
- My comments are a slave to the TV schedule. I tend to watch major schools much more than minor schools and I do not watch nearly as many “West Coast games” as “Eastern Games” simply because of the time difference. Ergo there is a bias regarding the players/teams I see more often than not.
- If a star player is injured when I tune in to see his team play, I obviously will not have any notes on him.
- Since I do not tune into most games with the intent to watch a specific player, I could easily miss seeing a very good player. I am hardly infallible.
Before focusing on specific positions and players eligible for this year’s Draft, I have an observation based on my “notepad scrawlings”:
- I think I watched as much college football last season as I did in the past. Nevertheless, I have what seems to be a much smaller stack of paper notes than in previous seasons.
- That means there is a paucity of players who stood out to me over the season. I don’t know if that means this is a lean year for NFL teams dipping into the draft pool or if it means I was not paying as close attention as in past times.
So, with those caveats and observations out in the open, let me plow ahead and talk about:
Quarterbacks: Here is an overall observation; I do not think this Draft is top heavy with “Blue Chip/Five-Star QB Prospects”. I saw 8 QBs that I think could be drafted this year, but this is not like last year where there were at least 3 or 4 QBs that were clearly going to be picked high in the first round.
- Cam Ward – Miami: Everyone has him as the overall #1 pick. My notes are much less flattering. “Strong arm and good-enough accuracy” but also “happy feet when rushed” are not the sorts of things I associate with the overall #1 pick. But I am not a scout or a GM and do not play one on TV.
- Shedeur Sanders – Colorado: Most folks have him as the second QB off the board. My comments were “very accurate on short passes” and “plays the screen game well” and “far less athletic than his genetics would imply”. He will go in the first round, but I think he is “a project – not a Day One Starter”.
- Jaxon Dart – Ole Miss: “Big, strong and can throw the deep ball very well”. Frankly, he might be the best pro QB from this year’s crop. First round pick.
- Jalen Milroe – Alabama: “Threat to run is his biggest weapon” and “needs time to develop touch and accuracy on his passes”. He’s “a project that could go on Day 2” of the Draft.
- Dillon Gabriel – Oregon: There was “lots of hype about hm winning the Heisman – not even close to reality”. He should be a late round pick as a project for a team with a solid starter.
- Quinn Ewers – Texas: “Good in all phases of the passing game but not great in any of them”. “Mid-round pick”.
- Riley Leonard – Notre Dame: “Don’t see his passing talents measuring up in the pros”. Maybe signed as an undrafted free agent?
- Will Howard – Ohio State: “Throws are really accurate” but “his receivers are so open I could hit many of them”. [Aside: And for the record, I am 81 years old with a sore throwing shoulder…]
Moving on to the Running Backs:
- Ashton Jeanty – Boise State: “Runs with power plus excellent speed”. “Sure-fire first round pick”. “Not asked to block very often so question mark there”. First round pick for sure …
- Cam Skattebo – Arizona State: “Low-to-the-road power running back” and “his motor never quits”. Early round pick makes sense here.
- TreVeyon Henderson – Ohio State: “Speed – – and more speed”. Late first round pick?
- Woody Marks – USC: “Good runner and good hands as a pass-catcher” “Mid-round pick.
- DJ Giddens – Kansas State: “Tough runner – fights for extra yards after hit”. “Fast enough but not ‘quick’”. “Mid-round pick?”
- Omarion Hampton – UNC: “Big back, runs hard, yards after contact”. “Good acceleration for a guy as big as he is”. “Not much of a blocker.” “3rd round or later?”
Moving on to the Wide Receivers:
- Travis Hunter – Colorado: “Top speed and great hands”. “Want to play him on offense to get him the ball more often than on defense”. “Big plays are his thing.” Should go Top-5. [Aside: Hunter has “threatened” to retire from football if he is not allowed to play both ways in the NFL. It is not clear to me how retiring from football achieves his goal of playing offense and defense in the same game. What do I know?]
- Emeka Egbuka – Ohio State: “Finds open spots all the time” and “very good downfield blocker.” He may never be a #1 WR in the NFL, but I think he is the second best WR that I saw for this Draft class. First round pick…
- Matthew Golden – Texas: “Speed, speed and some more speed”. “Stretches the defense”. “Good hands”. “Only knock is that he is not very big”. Second round?
- Eric Ayomanor – Stanford: “Big guy and fast enough” “Makes catches in traffic”. “Fights for yards after contact”. Maybe second day?
- Tre Harris – Ole Miss: “Screen graphic says 6’2” and 210 lbs.” I believe it; he is a big WR. “Good target in contested coverage”. “Not much of a blocker”. Possibly 3rd or 4th round.
- Arian Smith – Georgia: “Very fast but very small”. “Worth a late-round flyer”.
Moving on to the Tight Ends:
- Tyler Warren – Penn State: “Gets open and does not go down easy”. “Should be a Top-10 pick.” He is listed at 6’6” and 256 lbs. and still I have a note that says, “Outran two safeties for a TD”. Top-10 pick.
- Colston Loveland – Michigan: “Big guy who glides down the field on his routes”. “Good hands.” “So-so blocker”. Second or third round …
- Gunnar Helm – Texas: “Not real fast but real sure hands”. Late round pick.
Given that NFL teams move offensive line prospects all around the interior OL positions, I do not differentiate among interior offensive line players. I will note if a guy looks really good as a center since that position requires a skill that the other positions do not, Anyway, here are my notes on Offensive Linemen:
- Kelvin Banks – Texas: “Big and strong, he is excellent at power run blocking”. “Good pass blocker but not as good as on the run”. Second round?
- Tyler Booker – Alabama: “Very large man” “Clears out his area on run plays”. “Stops bull-rushers on pass plays”. First or second round pick here …
- Donovan Jackson – Ohio State: “Good on run plays and good pass protector”. “Not very fast”. Mid-round pick?
- Jackson Powers-Johnson – Oregon: “Very large man.” “Very good pass protector” “Can play center” Probably a second-round pick or maybe even late first round.
Before leaving offensive linemen, let me deviate from the norm here. Back around Thanksgiving last year, I got an email from a former colleague who has retired to the Williamsburg, VA area and has become a follower of Division 1-AA William and Mary football. He knows that #1 son went to William and Mary and every once in a while, he sends me a note about the athletic program there. His note last Fall had this in it:
“Charles Grant is a gigantic offensive tackle for The Tribe [William and Mary] and he was invited to play in the Senior Bowl from this FCS program. You haven’t seen him here but you might see him in the Senior Bowl and think he is worth a mention when you talk about the draft next year.”
I did tune in to the Senior Bowl and I did look for Charles Grant, but I never saw him on the field. It turns out he did not go to the Senior Bowl, but I don’t know why. Here is information about him from tribeathletics.com:
- Charles Grant – William and Mary: “He is 6’4” and 300 lbs.; he was a three-year starter; he was named as an FCS All-American in his junior year and in his senior year. He allowed only two sacks in his three years as a starter.”
Obviously, he did not play against the same level of opponent as did potential draftees from the Big-10 or the SEC. Nonetheless, Charles Grant was invited to the NFL Combine and the evaluation there says he “will eventually be an average starter” in the NFL. I will listen to hear his name on Day 3 of the Draft…
Moving over to the defensive side of the ball, I’ll start inside the defensive line with Defensive Tackles:
- Walter Nolen – Ole Miss: “Generates pass rush from inside” “May need to add weight to make it in the NFL” “Surprising speed for a DT.” I think he goes in the first round.
- Alfred Collins – Texas: “Huge human being” “Good run stopper and decent as a pass rusher”. I think he goes in the second round – – maybe third.
- Mason Graham – Michigan: “Never quits on a play”. “Not as big as others but a good run defender”
- Kenneth Grant – Michigan: “Large man but still very quick – – not fast” “How does anybody run inside on Michigan?” First round pick?
- Warren Brinson – Georgia: “Run stuffer when plays over the center” and “Tall with long arms is an asset in pass rushing”. “Not fast at all.”
- DeAndre Jules – South Carolina: “Big guy who stops run plays inside” “Not much of a pass rusher so not on the field for every play in NFL.” Late round pick?
- Jamaree Caldwell – Oregon: “Built like a fireplug” and “ Strong run defender” but “Not much inside pressure on pass plays”. Late round pick …
Moving outside to defensive ends – – or Edge players as is the current vernacular:
- Abdul Carter – Penn State: “Dominant pass rusher but only OK against the run”. “Gets a great jump on the snap” “Has to go in the Top-10 next season”
- Princely Umanmielen – Ole Miss: “Speed rusher who never gives up on a play” “Always somewhere in offensive backfield” First or second round?
- Jack Sawyer – Ohio State: “Relentless defender run or pass” “Strong against run – hard to get outside him” “Not as athletic as others” Maybe 3rd round?
- Jihaad Campbell – Alabama: “Attacks the run game hard” “Covers backs out of backfield on wheel routes” “Might need to add weight for NFL” Second or third round pick?
- Oluwafemi Oladejo – UCLA: “Nothing fancy or attention getting but every time they unpile, he is in the pile.” “Big enough and quick enough but nothing is outstanding.” Late round pick here.
- Ruke Orhorhoro – Clemson: “Very big and fast” “Plays the run well taking on blockers”. Late round pick …
Next are the Linebackers:
- Jaylon Walker – Georgia: I was obviously impressed with his speed because my note says, “Why isn’t he a WR?” The answer is probably contained in two other notes, “Fierce pass rusher” and “Good in pass coverage”. Probably round one or two …
- Danny Stutsman – Oklahoma: “A tackling machine” and “Will need to add weight for the pros” were my two notes. That probably means a Day 3 pick?
- Jack Kiser – Notre Dame: “Good speed always has him around the ball”. “Too small for NFL?” “Solid pass coverage”. Another Day 3 pick?
Now for the Defensive Backs. Note, like with offensive linemen, I lump corner backs and safeties into one group because NFL coaches move them around to fit defensive schemes.
- Malaki Starks – Georgia: “Does everything on defense.” “Really impressive as a blitzer.” “First rounder for sure.”
- Xavier Watts – Notre Dame: “Plays sideline to sideline at safety” “Good coverage and big hitter”. Second round?
- Jacob Parish – Kansas State: “Plays a physical game but he is a little guy” “Not sure he can stand up in NFL”. Late round pick or undrafted free agent?
- Nick Emmanwori – South Carolina: “Very big and tall DB” and “Big hitter” are the positive notes. “Not sure if he has NFL speed” is the negative note. Third or fourth round?
- Jabbar Muhammad – Oregon: “Tight coverage” “Too small for the pros” Probably a late round pick or maybe an undrafted free agent?
- Lathan Ransom – Ohio State: “Tough defender” and “Good coverage guy” would suggest second or third round.
As for Placekickers and Punters, I have no notes to inform any comments here; so, I’ll just move on …
Finally, today’s rant has been all about the potential shown by these football players hoping to “move up” and to compete at the highest level of the sport. Right now, NFL coaches and GMs see these players as having “potential” but as not yet certain they can compete at the highest level. So, I’ll close today with these words from an athlete – – in a different sport to be sure – – who faced this same situation of potential, Muggsy Bogues:
“No one knows how big your potential is, how big your heart is, when you start.”
But don’t get me wrong, I love sports………