James Franklin Out At Penn State

Back in August, I did a College Football Pre-Season “analysis” rant and put there six coaches at major college football programs who might be on a hot seat for this season.  James Franklin at Penn State was not on that list; and truth be told, his name never entered my mind as being even slightly in danger of being canned.

There was a “negative narrative” out there about Franklin and his teams.  They were always good enough to set up a late season “big game” that might lead to a championship game or something like that; they were normally not good enough to win that “big game” so the season ended on a downer even if the overall record was something like 12-2.  The Penn State fan base is an avid one but they never crossed the line into being delusional to the point where they thought playing for the national championship 3 years out of every 5 years was a birthright – – as is the case with some other schools I won’t mention here.  That “negative narrative” did not appear threatening to me.

However, after losing to Oregon at home on “White-Out Night” (not desirable but acceptable since Oregon seemed to be a rival contender for Big-10 Championship Game participation) and then losing at UCLA despite being a 24-point favorite, there was unrest among the common folk in Happy Valley.  Not to worry, Northwestern was coming to State College the next weekend and that would make things right with the Nittany Lions’ universe.

Not so.  Northwestern kicked off as a 21-point underdog and won the game outright in State College in front of more than 100,000 eye witnesses.  And in the paroxysms anger, frustration and rage, Penn State fired James Franklin.

If I understand the reports I have read about his contract, it cost the university $48M to fire Franklin for something other than “cause” as outlined in the contract.  His deal was for $8M per year with a “retention bonus” for each season that he was the head coach there through the end of the 2031 season.  So, before I go even one word further, do not worry for James Franklin’s family and their ability to keep food on the table.

In case you do not recall how Franklin wound up at Penn State in the first place, here is the Cliff Notes version:

  • Vandy hired Franklin after the 2010 season.  At that time, Vandy had had one winning season and one bowl appearance between 1983 and 2010.  Vandy was an SEC punching bag.
  • Franklin was at Vandy for 3 seasons; his Vandy teams went to bowl games in each of those three seasons and won two of those bowl games.  At the end of the 2013 season, James Franklin was a hot commodity and was seen as someone who could “turn things around” in a football program.
  • At the end of the 2013 season, Penn State football was in tatters.  Bill O’Brien had been the head coach there for two seasons after the Jerry Sandusky scandal that unseated Joe Paterno as the eternal coach at the school.  Football fortunes were stagnant in Happy Valley, and the school signed Franklin to put the team back on a course of “national relevance”.
  • From 2014 through 2024, Penn State had gone 102-42; it had been in bowl games every season except for the foreshortened one in 2020.

And here we are in 2025 …  The Nittany Lions began the season beating up on three cupcakes by a combined margin of 121 points.  Then came that “White Out” night encounter with Oregon and here we are two weeks after that “big game loss”.  And the schedule does not look good from here on out.

The Lions’ offense had been powered by Drew Allar at QB; he suffered an injury in the Northwestern game that will have him out for the rest of the season.  And here is the upcoming schedule:

  • At Iowa:  The Hawkeyes just pitched a shut-out against Wisconsin
  • At Ohio St.:  The Buckeyes would have been favored even if Allar was playing.
  • Vs. Indiana:  The Hoosiers just beat Oregon last weekend.
  • At Michigan St.:  That game still looks winnable.
  • Vs. Nebraska:  My “sleeper team” from last year is ranked in the Top 25 this year.
  • At Rutgers:  Losing to Rutgers would be full-scale ignominy for the Penn State faithful.

            Terry Smith will be the interim head coach for the Nittany Lions.  He is a former Penn State player and has been an assistant coach there for more than 10 years.  The program is in disarray, but the program is a prestigious one; so, the Athletic Director has time to sift through the possibilities to find someone who has shown the ability to “turn things around” for a football program.  Someone like James Franklin was back in 2014 …

Finally, since today has been about a beginning and an end, let me close with this observation by comedian George Burns:

“The secret of a good sermon is to have a good beginning and a good ending, then having the two as close together as possible.”

But don’t get me wrong, I love sports………

 

 

One thought on “James Franklin Out At Penn State”

  1. What a rollercoaster ride this season has been! Penn States firing of Franklin was a shocker, like finding out your favorite punching bag suddenly has a PhD. But hey, at least the AD now has a prime spot to find someone to turn things around, just like Vandy did back in the day. And the schedule ahead? Its like a game of Jenga, but with bigger stakes and fewer pieces. Who knew losing to Oregon could lead to such a cascade of events? Heres to hoping the interim coach and the new hires can hit a home run, or at least score a touchdown. As George Burns said, keep the beginning and ending close—preferably after the season ends!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *