February 13, 2007
2/13/07 - What’s The Deal In San Diego?
What is going on in San Diego? Less than a month ago, the owner of the Chargers had to intervene in the long-standing feud between Marty Schottenheimer and GM AJ Smith to declare that Schottenheimer would be the coach next year. Even so, both coordinators and two other assistant coaches left the Chargers for other opportunities in the league which has to tell you that all was not peaches and cream at “Chargers’ Park”. Now, the owner, Deal Spanos, does a 180 and fires Schottenheimer. All Marty did was go 14-2 last season, compile a 47-33 record in five seasons in San Diego and a record of 35-13 over the last three seasons. Look, I am a firm believer that good players are more important to a team than a good coach and that great players can make a good coach look a whole lot better than he actually is. But I really don’t understand how Marty Schottenheimer is the fall-guy for whatever shortcomings the owner may perceive after a 14-2 season.
And remember, the San Diego Padres kicked Bruce Bochy to the curb just a few months ago after he finished winning three consecutive NL West division titles. Can someone in San Diego please check to see if hallucinogens have leached into the town reservoir?
While you’re at it, can you explain to me what just happened with the NY Giants? When I read that they cut Lavar Arrington and Carlos Emmons, I was mildly surprised but not shocked. Father Time has eroded Arrington’s big play skills significantly and he never was a “steady, get-the-job-done, no-frills” kind of player. Emmons never lived up to the expectations the Giants had to have had for him when they signed him away from the Eagles. Nevertheless, it was a mile surprise to see both of them cut loose. Then I read that the Giants also cut Luke Pettigout. Say what? I thought he was the best OL on the team and they cut him in February? Yes, he was injured last year and maybe his recovery is not going well; that’s possible. But if he returns to his previous stature and ability, I think the Giants will look back on the decision to cut him very unhappily.
The newspapers in the Dallas all think new Cowboys’ coach, Wade Phillips, is a really nice guy who can fit into the “Texas milieu” because of his family ties to the Texas/Louisiana area. Phillips did have some success in Buffalo taking the Bills to the playoffs twice - - and they haven’t been there since he left. His tenure in Denver was hardly a positive one even with some guy named Elway at QB and his “interim stints” in Atlanta and New Orleans were not memorable. The most important thing for Phillips to do is not to inspire the Cowboys’ defense – that’s the conventional wisdom. What he really has to do is to allow Jerry Jones to have a completely free hand with regard to personnel decisions and he needs to stay out of any confrontational situations with T.O. that might cause Jerry Jones some public embarrassment. If he does those two things, he’ll be fine as the nominal coach of the Cowboys in the eyes of the owner/President/GM/shadow-coach. And that’s all that really matters…
I’ve read in various analytical pieces that it was Phillips’ success with the Chargers’ 3-4 defense that got him the job in Dallas where they have the personnel to play a 3-4 defense. All that’s fine and dandy, but that’s the same attribute that got him hired in Denver and in Buffalo and put him in those interim jobs in the past. However, it was his performance as a head coach in Denver and Buffalo that got him fired in both cities and it was the lack of any significant “bump” in Atlanta and New Orleans that prevented him from getting the head coaching job there on a permanent basis. So, why is all of this going to change in 2007?
The real winner in the Cowboys’ coaching sweepstakes might just have been Norv Turner. Norv’s record as a head coach is not all that hot; granted he worked for two really dysfunctional organizations in the past, but a career record of 59-83-1 isn’t a compelling entry on one’s résumé. Now, there is the perception that he didn’t get the job because he was not sufficiently “pliant” for job based on the special need to incorporate the views and actions of the owner/President/GM/shadow-coach in Dallas. Mild-mannered Clark Kent stood up on his hind legs and took a stand that may have cost him a job. That might just get him another job interview one of these days - - like maybe in San Diego? They interviewed him five years ago when Schottenheimer got the job…
I want to say one thing about Andy Reid taking a month-long leave of absence in Philly. What happened to the Reid family is a tragedy; any parent who would have to deal with the situations that two of Reid’s sons find themselves in without being stunned and confused and emotionally drained is a sorry excuse for a parent. In fact, that person – regardless of gender – would be a sorry excuse for a biped. This is not the time to pour out venom on Andy Reid or his family. Absent a whole lot more information on this matter or some egregiously self-serving statements/actions by parties to this matter, I will refrain from any nasty commentary.
A leave of absence from an NFL team by a head coach is not a commonplace event. In fact, the only analogous situation I can recall is when Mike Martz took a medical leave of absence from the St. Louis Rams a few years ago because he had some form of heart disease that was life threatening and required his hospitalization. As I said, the situations are analogous but hardly the same.
It’s a recurring theme in these rants that there are too many college football teams in bowl games and too many NBA teams in the NBA playoffs and too many NHL teams in the Stanley Cup playoffs. The NCAA and the NBA and the NHL reward mediocrity. This morning, I received an e-mail from a regular reader who resides in Melbourne, Australia telling me that the National Basketball League there makes the NCAA, NBA and NHL look pretty good on this front. There are 12 teams in the Australian NBL; 8 of those 12 teams are seeded into a playoff format. The 8th seed in this year’s tournament (the Singapore Slingers) according to my correspondent had a regular season record of 13-20; they open the Phillips Championship tournament against the Townsville Crocodiles imminently. The NBL is indeed a very generous organization with regard to rewarding sporting “achievement” when 13-20 is a record worthy of inclusion.
Time for a Quick Quiz. In 200 words or less please evaluate:
What would be more preferable – a baseball season without Barry Bonds or a football season without Terrell Owens?
No extra credit will be given for any references outside the sports of football and baseball even if you can concoct a scenario where either or both of these goofs play for Mark Cuban…
Finally, I’ve had less than nice things to say about the Pro Bowl. In fact, I’ve suggested on many occasions that the game be canceled and never reinstated. However, Greg Cote’s evaluation of the Pro Bowl in the Miami Herald is even less flattering than my suggestion to stop playing the damned game:
“They played the Pro Bowl Saturday in Honolulu. It’s the game guys make excuses not to play in, the annual anticlimax to the NFL season. The Super Bowl being followed by the Pro Bowl is sort of like an exquisite meal being followed by a bowel movement.”
But don’t get me wrong, I love sports…
Comments(5)